The Hidden Cost of Self-Reliance


The AOA Leadership Newsletter

Hi Reader,

I''ll be holding a rare Q&A on February 2, exclusive for leaders who are interested in learning more about how we approach leadership and the Council.

You'll get the chance to ask questions about the program, as well as ask any strategy questions you may have for Rapid coaching.

Reserve your seat here.

The Hidden Cost of Self-Reliance

Self-reliance began the first time you realized you weren’t going to be taken care of.

It was when you learned, often at a young age, that you needed to take care of your caregivers, whether it was your parents, grandparents, or teachers. Perhaps you needed to make them happy, relieve their fear, or stop their criticism.

The belief underneath is: “People aren’t going to be there for me. So I need to take care of myself.”

What most people miss about self-reliance is that everyone carries this pattern to some degree. The question isn’t whether it’s present, but how deeply it’s running your life.

Self-reliance has a lot of upsides. It’s often the thing that drives people to be successful. But it can also have lots of negative side-effects. Here are some ways self-reliance can end up impacting your company:

1. You take responsibility for your team's emotions

When a child learns it’s their job to keep caregivers regulated, they carry that responsibility forward. As a leader, this shows up as managing feelings instead of setting direction, taking responsibility for people and their outcomes, and a constant feeling of obligation.

Over time, this creates resentment in the leader and the employees. You feel like you need to take care of others in ways that you’re not actually able to. And the company as a whole starts to organize around protecting feelings instead of producing outcomes.

2. You rarely share your wants

Self-reliance teaches you that wanting is dangerous. If your job was to take care of your caregivers, your wants become secondary, invisible, or not allowed.

As a leader, this creates two problems at once. One, you don’t clearly express what you want, so your team doesn’t know how to win. And two, the wants that do surface rarely come out cleanly.

The result is fear. Your team doesn’t know what success looks like, so they often feel scared because they don’t know if they’re doing a good job, and end up in inefficient loops because they’re trying to guess what will keep you happy.

3. You have a hard time asking for help

When a child learns their job is to take care of others, asking for help feels foreign, weak, or even selfish. But your desire for help doesn’t just disappear, it gets stuck.

This creates a paradox: Wanting help while pushing it away. The stronger your self-reliance, the more you secretly wish that someone can someday take care of you.

But at the same time, you reject or invalidate the help that’s actually available by asking in ways that seem indirect, resentful, vague, or desperate. This repels people, so they’re less likely to help. And this reinforces the original belief that “No one will help me.”

4. You don’t own your power

Most self-reliant leaders don’t trust authority, because your early authority figures were unsafe, unreliable, or emotionally costly. This creates a double bind with power. You don’t want anyone to have power over you, yet you also feel uncomfortable in authority positions, because of what you experienced authority to mean.

The result is a desire for power without fully being able to own it. And that creates power vacuums. It creates a leader who is technically in charge, but not fully occupying the role. A leader who doesn’t feel comfortable telling others what to do when it’s needed. And when the team sees this vacuum, they feel unsafe or step in to fill it. This leads to unnecessary conflict or drama.

Big Love,

Joe

This newsletter is brought to you by The Council.

Art of Accomplishment

Read more from Art of Accomplishment

Hi Reader, A few years ago, I worked with a leadership team at a Series C software company. On paper, they were perfectly aligned. Strategic plans were approved unanimously. Everyone nodded in meetings. Decisions passed without friction. And yet nothing moved. Projects stalled, timelines slipped, and initiatives that everyone had "agreed to" kept getting quietly deprioritized. The CEO was baffled. How could a team that agreed on everything execute on nothing? When we dug in, we found the...

Hi Reader, A few years ago, I worked with the CEO of a fast-growing company. He was deeply committed to his people: Generous with equity, flexible on hours, always available. But his company had a problem. They couldn't kill anything. Every initiative seemed to live forever. Their roadmap was cluttered with half-finished projects. Teams were stretched thin, saying yes to everything and finishing nothing. He kept trying to fix it with reorgs, new prioritization frameworks, or hiring new...

Hi Reader, In our last email, we explored the first pillar: We all want to be part of something exceptional. The desire to contribute, to win together, to be part of something meaningful are all already there in your people. The work is about unlocking that hunger. Let's dive in to the second pillar of fulling leadership: Pillar Two: Where it hurts is where you'll grow We point to this frequently in terms of self-discovery: Your triggers are a gift. They tell you where your unexamined...